South Galway Floods – Public Consultation Thu 3rd May

Your input and local knowledge is important to ensure the development of an informed publicly acceptable scheme.  It’s time to have your say!
gortlowlandspublicconsultation1.JPG
Galway County Council intend to progress a flood relief scheme to alleviate flooding which has impacted the Gort Lowlands area. For more information you can see the leaflet below:

gortlowlandsfloodreliefleaflet

Mott MacDonald has been appointed by Galway County Council to carry out an Environmental Assessment of the proposed South Galway (Gort Lowlands) Flood Relief Scheme.  The purpose of this Public Consultation Day is to seek initial views from the public in relation to the key issues that should be addressed as part of the South Galway (Gort Lowlands) Flood Relief Scheme, and to highlight points of local importance that may constrain the design of potential flood alleviation measures.
Please call into Sullivan’s Hotel, on Thu 3rd May 2018 between 3pm and 9pm and give your feedback on the flooding there,.  You can fill out this questionnaire there, or at home and send it to the communications co-ordinator for the scheme, Ms. Rita Mansfield
By post:
Ms. Rita Mansfield
South Galway (Gort Lowlands) Flood Relief Scheme Communications Coordinator
Mott MacDonald Ireland Ltd., 5 Eastgate Avenue, Little Island, Co. Cork
By e-mail:

 

Please give your support to the community that has had to endure 5+ severe flooding events since 1990 – It’s threatening our farming community, our schools, our heritage and our national parks (The Killing of Coole)
Thanks. 

-David Murray 

Advertisements

The Killing of Coole

Coole Park is a nature reserve and one of the most beautiful areas in Ireland with a rich mix of natural beauty, a vibrant heritage history and a special area of unique environmental importance.  We see however that with extreme weather events – all of these aspects of Coole Park are being very badly threatened. We need to ensure that Coole Park is well protected by the emerging South Galway Flood Relief scheme.

The Walled Garden

In 1768 Robert Gregory,  Chairman of the East India Company, bought 600 acres from Oliver Martyn of Tulira and this became the foundation of Coole Park as we know it today.  In 1770 he built Coole house and also started the construction of a Walled Garden in 1775.  In 1776, it is reported in ‘A Tour of Ireland’ that many miles of walls are being constructed and also that “Mr Gregory has a very noble nursery, from which he is making plantations, which will soon be of great ornament to the country”.   As part of the Walled Garden, beech trees and a line of Yew trees are planted. Richard Gregory continued the work and also had a bust of Maecenas transported from Italy.

Coole Park is famous for its Autograph Tree and Lady Gregory (Wife of Robert Gregory’s great grandson) also had a fondness for the Yew and in ‘Gods and Fighting Man’,  called it ‘the most beautiful of the wood’.  There are very frequent reference to the line of Yew trees in visitor reports to Coole House.

“That afternoon I found the garden….. I went slowly along, crushing rosemary between my fingers, and wondering at the dark groups of stately Irish yews.”  Signe Toksvig, 1921

Even in the Ordinance Survey 1838 maps we see an outline of the walled garden with the paths, pumps and the  line of ‘evergreen’ trees where the current Yews stand.
 walledgarden1

And until recently this is what the Walled Garden looked with the line of yew trees in the centre and the Autograph tree on the left.

walledGarden2
Aerial View of the Walled Garden at Coole. (Courtesy of Leann Harmon)
OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
The Yews – Pre-2015

These yew trees (Taxus baccata) have become a distinct feature of Coole Park and can reach 400 to 600 years of age and beyond.

 Nature Reserve,  Special Protected area and Special Area of Conservation

In 1983, Coole Park, GarryLand was designated a Nature Reserve which “includes woodland and lake ecosystems which are of scientific interest and that the said ecosystems are likely to benefit if measures are taken for their protection”

 

NatureReserve.gif

It is also a Special Protection Area (SPA) under the E.U. Birds Directive, of special conservation interest for Whooper Swan.  Lastly, it is a Special Area of Conservation (SAC)  with special focus on:

  • Natural eutrophic lakes with Magnopotamion or Hydrocharition – type vegetation
  • Turloughs
  • Rivers with muddy banks with Chenopodion rubri p.p. and Bidention
  • Juniperus communis formations on heaths or calcareous grasslands
  • Semi-natural dry grasslands and scrubland facies on calcareous substrates (Festuco-Brometalia) (* important orchid sites)
  • Limestone pavements
  • Taxus baccata woods of the British Isles  (The Yew)

Coole-Park/Garryland is therefore one of the most specially protected areas in Ireland with significant ecological benefit. It is operated by the Irish National Parks & Wildlife Service (NPWS) who are part of the Department of Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht,  currently under Minister Josepha Madigan T.D.  It is their responsibility to ensure that Coole Park (and other Turlough areas) are protected.

cooleSac

Coole Park is now under significant threat from several flooding events and we need to ensure that those that are responsible for its protection are made aware of their responsibilities and do their jobs.

Severe Flooding

Several times in the past 30 years Coole Park has experienced severe flooding – in fact some of the worst flooding in several hundred years. While local people experienced the worst flooding seen in the area in their lifetime – Coole park was subject to an even starker picture –  that of experiencing the worst flooding in centuries –  many of the famous Yew trees that have been around for and estimated 220 years were destroyed by the flooding in Winter 2016 and water was very close to the autograph tree.

cooleParkFlood
The Walled Garden in Flood (28th Dec 2015)  – Courtesy of Sean Brady Aerial Photography

In the past 30 years, we have had a large set of hydrology changes in the South Galway / Kinvara Catchment.  The Slieve Aughty mountains now have significant developments around forestry and windfarms (with their corresponding roads and drains).  Uplands farming improvements have resulted in land being drained more than in times past.    In the Slieve Aughty lowlands there have been rivers streamlined, new culverts installed and inadvertently, some swallow-holes damaged and overflow channels obstructed through land reclamation.

Whatever the reason for hydrology changes the consequence is that Coole Park has become the defacto dumping ground and holding site for enormous amounts of contaminated flood water in South Galway.  This flood water includes pollutants and contaminents from septic tanks, farmyard slurry tanks and farmyard pollutants as well as farmland run-off and significant amounts of silting.  This not only has severe consequences for the environment and human health but it also drastically affects the overall community as the water levels threaten homes, businesses, churches and severely restricts access around several communities in South Galway.

Flooding Impacts

As Coole lake has unfortunately become the dumping ground for run-off water from the Slieve Aughty mountains – there are many significant consequences.

  • Flooding water damage to trees
  • Pollution
  • Wildlife impacts
  • Silting
  • Damage to park amenities
  • Flooding of outlying areas
  • Tourism and Heritage
  • Human Health
  • Farmyard flooding

Flooding water damage to trees

In 1995, 2009 and 2014 and 2015, the famous Walled Garden in Coole Park was inundated with flooding – 2015 being the highest levels.  It covered the picnic benches, flooded the shelters and saturated may of the yew trees and shrubs.  4 of the main yew trees did not fully recover and have since died

Nice weather for retrievers

yew1.JPG

These Yew trees had survived over 220 years and it shows that the levels of recent flooding allowed in Coole Park are record levels.   Also, it wasn’t just these Yew trees.   A large Yew tree at the Walled Garden car park was damaged, and an copse of Yew trees in Garryland was also severely damaged as well as several Yew tree near Newtown.  Coole Park is a Special Area of conservation (SAC) and Yew Tree (Taxus Baccus) woodlands are called out specifically in this.  We are therefore failing in adequate protection of this SAC.

Another impact on woodland is that flooding causes leaves the forest more vulnerable to storms.  In 2014, there was significant damage to the forest into which Coole Lake had flooded. The waterlogged ground made trees more susceptible to falling in windy conditions.  This is what happened the Yew tree a the Walled Garden Car Park  in Winter 2015

Water levels rose close to the base of the famous Autograph tree which would have made it more vulnerable to falling

Pollution

Coole lake received waters from many other flooded areas and subsequently caused flooding in areas closer to Coole (Kiltartan, Raheen, Glenbrack, Tierneevin,  etc) .  This involved a lot of farmyard flooding: (Photos : Courtesy of Sean Brady, Aerial Photography)


balllyhugh2
In this picture it is very clear to see the farmyard slurry contaminating the water system
ballkhugh
It is not just the farmyard slurry but many other pollutants that get into the system
tierneevin1.jpg
Farmyard in Tierneevin
glenbrackfloodingGort
A farm shed in Glenbrack completely immersed in flood water – Water levels should not be allowed to rise to these levels!

A very familiar site all around Coole Lake –  black plastic silage bags caught high-up in the trees. (Newtown Turlough- Coole-Garryland SAC

Several farm yards  around the area are 13m above sea level. In 2015,  Coole Lake rose to 14.78m,  and it overflowed into many farmyards, homes and businesses.  Common farmyard pollutants can include chemical fertiliser, engine oil, grease, fuel, silage wrap, weed killer, pesticides, veterinary medicine etc.  Also at this stage the contents of over 40 septic tanks were being washed into Coole lake.

5937380.jpg
We see here the plastic bottles being washed up close the hut (Courtesy of Burren Photography)

In many places, there were black plastic silage wrap spread through trees and shrubs all over the park.   With extremely high-level allowed in Coole, this pollution will also be  spread into the lower-lying turloughs and SACs.

 

Wildlife impacts

Pollution has a devastating on many animals and habitats. In a report from the UK on flooding it states –  “Most natural sites are able to take occasional flooding, but any water polluted by overflowing drains, septic tanks or pesticides from farms and parks is likely to have exacted a toll on many animals.” In addition to these devastating effects of pollution, during the floods of Winter 2015 some habitats were completely flooded and hibernating animals sought refuge from flood waters

h1
Many hibernating mammels were displaced and killed by the several flooding

Another key impact on an SAC is the Kiltartan Cave SAC (Probably the smallest SAC in Ireland!)

kiltartanSAC

This is an 800m long cave and is a habitat for a colony of bats and the SAC is to protect this habitat.  This is the key reason the now famous ‘bat-bridge’ was built (at substantial cost) across the M18 Motorway.  According to Tony Collins, project engineer for the M18 motorway,   it allows lesser horseshoe bats to safely cross the motorway to feeding grounds at Coole Park from their roosting site at Kiltartan Cave which were separated by the motorway. [6]

With extreme levels of flooding in Coole, this habitat is lost and the bat population displaced – something which grates against the EU habitats directive.

Silting

As the water leves of Coole Lake rose, the rivers feeding it lost pressure and this resulted in significant amount of silt deposits. This has a big impact on the natural ecosystem, marine life as well as impacting hydrology of the system.

 

silting.JPG
After Winter flooding 2009, there were huge silt banks on the Kiltartan River at Polldeelin
silting2.JPG
The river after the rise into Coole Lake is very silted

Damage to park amenities

TThe main damage to Coole Park amenities was around the walled Garden and picnic area.  Also the little hut beside the river had its roof lifed too and damaged. The Coole Park Interpretative centre was became flooded. In 2015, there was as estimated  €20,000 of damage done around Coole Park amenities – There is also a potential knock-on impact to  tourism.

Coole Lake environment and upstream flooding

Coole Lake provides a significant amount of attenuation for South Galway, however when it is allowed to reach the levels it did in 2015 is has a huge impact across multiple communities.

coolelakelevels.JPG

Local Flooding from Coole

On a normal Summer, Kiltartan Church is 2 KM away from Coole Park and the lake levels can be just 5m above sea level (AOD) .   The door step at Kiltartan Church is 14.52m Above sea level (AOD) .

In Winter 2015, Coole Lake rose to 14.78m therefore Coole lake essentially backed into Kiltartan Church to a height of 26cm.  (OPW Levels)

 

kiltartanChurch.jpg
In Winter 2015, the level of Coole lake was 18 inches into Kiltartan Church.

Similarly Tierneevin is 2km from Coole lake in the summer and Coole lake backed up into this area as well.  this flooding homes, septic tanks, farmyards, this is what happens if the maximum level of Coole Lake is not maintained.

Coole Lake also flooded homes and businesses in Raheen, Crannagh, Glenbrack and Tierneevin.

According to McCormick/Naughton (GSI/Trinity) ,  the levels of water in the groundwater system can influenced flow rates in a Karst system. and highlights examples where the backwater effect of flooding at the downstream sink reduces the hydraulic gradient and increases upstream river levels. [1] High Coole lake levels mean a drop in pressure upstream causing more water to gather. Swallow holes almost completely stop working in Kiltartan, Roo and Tierneevin  as Coole Lake level back into them and some of the other flows are impacted – even as far back as Ballylee and Blackrock.

Access

As Coole lake flooded it blocked many roads all around its periphery.  The following list details  the amount of time roads were closed in the area around Coole, Garryland, Ballynastaigue

Kiltartan/Corker 91
Crannagh 81
Coole/ Glenbrack
21
Tierneevin
152
Caherglassaun
86
Roo 119

It also flooded the M18 motorway construction for several weeks.

Health Impacts

There is a significant threat to human health from this flooding scenario.   The mental stress and anguish of having your home or livelihood threatened is enormous.  Also many people were affected the severe isolation – not being able to leave your home conveniently.  The threat to physical health by contaminated water and health schemes is significant and private wells can continue to be contaminated long after flood water recedes.

Impacts on Farming

As Coole Lake rose, it covered a large amount of farmland and stayed on the land . Many farms in the area had to be reseeded at a significant cost to the farmer.  As with wildlife, another significant threat is that to farm animals and threat to their health from contaminated flood water.

Tourism and Heritage Impacts

Coole Park is a very attractive destination in the west of Ireland.  Trip Advisor shows it as the #1 attraction with 4.5/5 star reviews.

cooletripadvisor

An article in the New York times explores this area  and indicated that “The grounds are now a national park and preserve of manicured gardens and paths beneath majestic yews.”

The Irish Examiner highlights that “Continuing eastward around the park’s periphery, we entered the Walled Garden through a bright red gate. The scene within was one of classic beauty, manicured lawns, gazebos, picnic tables, a line of yews and the Autography Tree, a copper beech inscribed with the names of the Irish and Anglo-Irish literary greats of the last century.”

Allowing Coole Park to flood increases the risk of damage to the park, the infrastructure, the trees and the wildlife and therefore also to the Tourist potential of the area.

Putting it all in perspective

The following infographic gives a summary of the situation.  Info is compiled from OPW recorded levels and GPS aided levels.

CoolelevelsInfographic.JPG

Here are a number of facts.

  • Coole Lake minimum levels are around the 3M (Above Sea level /AOD)
  • Coole Lake maximum level recorded level in 2015 was 14.78 (OPW)
  • Coole Lake can rise to levels of 11m without any major flood threat, which is still an 8m (26ft)  difference from low summer levels.
  • Once Coole Lake level rises above 12m, road access is impacted and farmyards are threatened.
  • Once Coole Lake level rises above 13m, septic tanks and farmyards start to flood and homes are threatened.
  • Once Coole Lake level above 14m, the underground systems (Kiltartan, Tierneevin and Roo) are no longer working and homes start to flood.
  • Once Coole Lake reach 14.5m, several homes are flooding, up to 15 septic tanks are under water and many homes are now threatened

Solutions

Solving the flooding in Coole Park is a not a choice – it’s mandatory Coole Park is one of the most protected areas in Ireland and allowing severe flooding is devastating to the nature reserve,  several communities and in fact against EU law.   The organisation accountable for Coole Park nature reserve and owns the responsibility for ensuring this is adequately protected against threats (including flooding ) is the National Parks and Wildlife service – NPWS.

We have the best possible chance at getting a right solution here as the South Galway/Gort Lowlands Flood Relief Scheme gets underway.  Galway County council is running the project, we now have design consultants, environmental consultants working toward getting a solution.

The NPWS will also play a key role here according to Dr Enda Mooney, regional Manager, the NPWS is committed to “working  constructively with the design team for the South Galway flood relief scheme and Galway Co. Council to help steer the proposed scheme through the legal requirements under national and European legislation.”

The South Galway Flood Relief Committee has had several meetings over the past 2 years with Dr Mooney to try and demystify the situation that will enable flood relief solutions to progress seamless so that the South Galway Community gets its flood relief solution and that also keep to the letter of EU legislation. We’ve made some great progress on certain aspects and there some very good collaboration here and overall I feel that the NPWS has stepped up the plate.    However, there are still some areas of concern that need to be smoothed out and these will be outlined in the next article which will go into a bit more detail on these issues.

Coole Park was developed by the Gregory’s for hundreds of years and has become a magnificant nature park, with strong cultural and heritage ties.  It was left in the care of the Government in 1927 and taken over by the Forest Service and since 1987 it is  now in the care of the NPWS.  They now have a key reponsibility here to be part of the solution and help and advise the consultants to get a full flood relief solution that will help the South Galway Community and halt the killing of Coole.

In the meantime if you feel strongly about helping to save Coole Park from future serious flooding and in addition to helping the many people affected by flooding in South Galway – please share this  with as many people as you can.  Please comment and leave feedback because it’s our collective voice that can have an impact here.

Thanks!

David Murray, Chair South Galway Flood Relief Committee

References

 

 

South Galway Flooding Survey

survey

As outlined in a 2018 update, the first stage of the South Galway Flood Relief Scheme is a feasibility study and flood risk assessment.   As part of these works the design Consultant Ryan Hanley will be commencing threshold surveys starting during next week of properties in or adjacent to flood zones in the study area.  These surveys are mainly focused on getting information on flood threats and flood extent and not on flooding damage -This nformation can be gathered during later public consultations sessions.

A team from Ryan Hanley will be calling to properties and will have identification and a letter from the OPW.  The key information that will be collected from property owners during the survey will include:

  • the property owner name and address,
  • property use (house, farm slatted shed, commercial premises etc.)
  • Age and construction of the property
  • finished floor level of the property (including basements, split levels etc.),
  • the access level,
  • septic tank location, slatted sheds locations, fuel storage locations, etc.
  • peak flood levels from past events (including 2009, 2015/ 2016, 1995) at or in the vicinity of the property
  • flood impact duration during events
  • brief summary of flood damage (any additional detailed information will be collected at the Public Consultation event).
  • was access to the property cut-off, where did the road / access flood etc., to what depth and for how long, how frequent, what was the length of diversion required if one was possible.
  • External Photograph of the property
  • in some cases, adjacent lands ownership and any knowledge on ground conditions (i.e. is rock near the surface)

This is vital infomation to gather to understand flooding levels and threats and in conjunction with addtional feedback during public consultation (Proposed for sometime in May)

Please support  – Let your neighbours know and please share this if you can.

regards

-David Murray,

Chair, South Galway Flood Relief Committee.

PS:Please don’t underestimate the impact you have by simply liking,commenting on or sharing this.